Articles Posted in Litigation Process

A deposition is a tool used primarily in civil lawsuits for uncovering evidence before an actual trial.  In theory and in fact, depositions help resolve cases before trial because each person involved in the case can learn the facts from his or her opponent and from independent witnesses.

Depositions usually take place in a conference room in the office of one of the lawyers involved in the case.  One or more lawyers for each party to the lawsuit is present.  The parties to the lawsuit are often present, but need not be present unless they are going to testify. 

The deposition itself is sworn testimony.  The person giving the testimony is called the "deponent."  The deponent is asked questions by the lawyers for the parties in the case.  The questions and the answers to those questions are recorded by a court reporter and, sometimes, also recorded on video.  The deponent has a right to have his or her lawyer present.

I have been summoned to jury duty in civil court.  Am I going to be able to ask questions of the witnesses at trial or do I just have to sit there and listen?

Relatively new changes to Tennessee law permit jurors to ask questions under certain circumstances.  The judge will instruct you what to do if you want to ask a question.

Do not be offended if the judge refuses to ask the question you want to ask.  The law of evidence prohibits a jury from considering some types of information.  (For example, you cannot know that the person who is being sued has liability insurance that will pay any money owed.  You also are not ordinarily permitted to know about settlement discussions.)  In addition, the evidence may be presented at a later time in the trial and judge may want the evidence to be introduced at that time.

The Circuit Court Clerk’s Office has released the data concerning tort jury trials in Nashville and Davidson County for February, 2012.  "Tort" cases are civil lawsuits involving injuries, death or other losses from automobile accidents, truck crashes, fall-downs, medical malpractice, dog-bites, and any other type of event that causes injury or death

Only four tort cases were tried to juries in the entire month, and three of them were medical malpractice (now called "health care liability") cases.  One of those cases was settled after jury selection and opening statements – the amount of the settlement was not disclosed.  One health care liability case resulted in a mistrial and the other resulted in a verdict for the health care providers.

The only other trial was a personal injury case.  The Court directed a verdict for the defense in that case, and thus a jury was not permitted to decide it.

I was hit by a Post Office truck.  How do I get my medical bills, lost wages, and other compensation paid to me?

If the truck was in fact owned and operated by the U.S. Post Office, you must file a formal notice of claim with the Post Office.  You must do this within two years of the date of your accident.  The Post Office then has at least six months to deny, approve, review or negotiate the claim.  If the claim is not resolved in six months, you have the right to file suit in federal court to protect your rights.

The claims and lawsuit process can be very complicated.  You would be wish to consult with a lawyer before taking legal action.  Our firm, the Law Offices of John Day, P.C., has handled claims against the federal government on many occasions, most recently resolving a medical negligence claim against a Veteran’s Administration Hospital.

I want to settle my personal injury case.  I would take less money now that I would later at trial, but I don’t want to make an offer and have the jury know that I will take less money that I would want it the case were tried.  Is the jury told about settlement offers?

Absent extraordinary circumstances, the jury is never told about any aspect of settlement discussions, must less the amount of any settlement proposal.

This is true even if the defense makes an offer before trial and then stands up and court and says you are entitled to nothing at all or an amount less than you were offered before trial.  All settlement discussions are "off the record" and thus are rarely admissible into evidence.

 

There were only four personal injury jury trials in Nashville (Davidson County) Tennessee in January 2012.

One of the cases was a medical malpractice (health care liability) case. The case resulted in verdict the defendant health care provider.

Another jury trial was a malicious prosecution case. Once again, a jury verdict for the defense was entered.

I have an automobile accident  case.  My lawyer is often on the phone when I call and my call is forwarded to his paralegal.  What do paralegals do?

You didn’t hire a lawyer, you hired a law firm.  In our firm a team of people works together to help every client.  The paralegal is an important part of the team.

Our law firm’s paralegals are very involved in every case.  They help us communicate with clients and do many other important tasks.

The Clerk of the Circuit Courts for Davidson County, Tennessee has released the following statistics for jury trials for 2011:

  • There were 10 health care liability (medical malpractice) jury trials.  The health care providers won six of those cases, the patient won two, and the other two cases resulted in a hung jury.
  • There were 36 auto liability cases tried, 22 of those to a jury.  The plaintiff won 25 of those cases.  Note, however, that the word "won" means that the plaintiff recovered some amount of money – not that the amount beat the defendant’s last offer or was otherwise a reasonable amount.
  • There were only two jury trials in December, 2011 one of which was a health care liability case (defense verdict) and one of which was an auto case (case dismissed by judge).

Despite what one reads in the papers or hears on the news, there are relatively few jury trials.  This number has steadily decreased across the entire state for many years.

The general rule in Tennessee is that a personal injury lawsuit for an adult must be filed within one year of the date of an incident causing an injury.   The failure to file a lawsuit on time will result in a loss of the right to bring a claim even if the case is otherwise valid

There are several exceptions to that rule, some that shorten the period in which a lawsuit must be filed and other exceptions which lengthen the period for action.  For instance, if you are injured by a defective or unreasonably dangerous product you must bring your claim within one year of the date of the injury but also within ten years of the date the product was sold to the first user or consumer.  

For example, assume that you were hurt on January 31, 2012 because of a defect in a car that was sold to the first user or consumer on June 30, 2002.  Under Tennessee law, you would have only five months to file a lawsuit against the car manufacturer or the manufacturer of the part or parts that were defective.

I was injured in a car wreck and have been out of work for months.  Money is very tight.  I spoke with a lawyer and he told me he could loan me $1000 a month until my case settles.  He also said that I do not have to pay interest.  That seems like a good deal to me, but another lawyer I spoke with refused to do it, saying it was not ethical.  What’s the story?

The second attorney you spoke with was correct.  In Tennessee it is unethical for an attorney to loan you money while he or she is representing you in a case.   An attorney who promises to do so or actually does so should be reported to the Tennessee Board of Professional Responsibility at 800.486.5714.   This sort of conduct can result in discipline against the attorney, including the loss of his  law license.

Why should you care about the ethical failings of an attorney?  If the attorney is willing to risk his or her law license to get  your case, do you really think you can trust them to represent you with your best interests in mind?  

Contact Information