Articles Posted in Litigation Process

I was in a car accident in Springfield, Tennessee.  I was hurt but I am not sure that I want to get involved in a lawsuit because I don’t want to give a deposition.  I really don’t understand what a deposition is but my friend said she had to give a deposition and that it was bad.  What is a deposition anyway? 

A deposition is testimony given by a the person bring a lawsuit (the plaintiff) or the person who was sued (the defendant) or witness in a lawsuit before the case actually goes to trial. The person giving the statement is called the deponent. 

A deposition is usually taken in the office of one of the lawyers involved in the case, although I have taken depositions in conference rooms, motel rooms and, one time, a bar.  

I am in a lawsuit over a car accident that wasn’t my fault.  The insurance company wants to see my old medical records.  What does my past medical treatment have to do with my  car wreck case involving a broken hip? 

Answer: Your medical history is important in any case in which you are claiming to have suffered a physical or psychological injury as a result of someone else’s negligent or intentional act. Your medical history establishes the baseline of your physical or psychological well being before the injury. You can only recover in the lawsuit for the injury caused by the act or omission of the responsible person. You may not recover damages for physical and mental suffering or medical care necessitated by preexisting conditions. When a preexisting condition is made worse you can recover damages for the worsening of the condition. Your medical history will be important to proving this claim. 

In your particular case, the insurance company will be looking to see if you had a prior hip problem or other medical problem that affected your overall well-being or your able to work or enjoy recreational activities.  

Here are the results from the jury trials in Nashville, Davidson County, Tennessee Circuit Court in October 2011:

  • Health Care Liability ( Medical Malpractice)   

                      –  3 trials, two defense verdicts, one hung jury

  • Slip and Fall  

                         – Settled after 6 days of trial

I have a lawsuit pending and my lawyer says that the other side has filed something called a "motion."  What is a motion?
 
A motion is a request by a party to the lawsuit to have the court rule on some issue.   A motion is a way of getting the court to resolve an issue between the parties to the lawsuit that they cannot work out between themselves.
 
For instance, under the law interrogatories (written questions one side of a lawsuit can sent to the other side of the case to learn information) must be answered in thirty days.  If interrogatories are sent but are not responded to within thirty days, a motion can be filed.  The motion asked the court to compel an answer to the interrogatories.

Here is a list of the number of jury trials in personal injury, wrongful death and other tort law trials in Tennessee for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2010 (the most recent year for which data is available):

Davidson County – 34

Montgomery County – 13

As a Tennessee personal injury lawyer, I try to keep up with the results of personal injury and wrongful death jury trials in Davidson County (Nashville) and other cities in Tennessee.  

Here are the results of the personal injury trials in Davidson County, Tennessee during the month of September, 2011:

  • Automobile Accident Case – Verdict for the Plaintiff for $7500
  • Automobile Accident Case – Hung Jury
  • Civil Assault – Verdict for the Plaintiff for $100,000
  • Automobile Accident Case – Verdict for the Plaintiff for $7430
  • Automobile Accident Case – Verdict for the Plaintiff for $10,041
  • Medical Malpractice Case – Verdict for the Plaintiff for $1,004,817 

This information was collected by Clerk of Court.

I am involved in a lawsuit and I had to answer interrogatories.  How do lawyers use interrogatories at trial?

Interrogatories are written questions sent from one party in a lawsuit to an opposing party about issues related to the lawsuit.  For example, in a lawsuit arising from a motor vehicle collision, each driver may send interrogatories to the other ask for driving histories, including whether the opposing driver has ever received a driving citation. The party responding to interrogatories must sign a statement swearing or affirming that the responses to the interrogatories are true.

How are answers used at trial?   Assume for example that you were served with an interrogatory that asked if you were aware of any witness to the car wreck involved in the case.  Assume that you said in answer to the interrogatory that  you were not aware of any witnesses, but then attempted to call an eyewitness at trial.  Unless the opposing party had knowledge of the eyewitness by some other means, the trial judge may well exclude the eyewitness from testifying at trial because you did not include the name and address of the eyewitness in your interrogatory answers.  

I am a truck driver  with a big trucking company in Clarksville, Tennessee.  I hurt my back unloading a truck.  The doctor says that I need an MRI but my boss says they are too expensive.  Does my employer have to pay for the MRI? 

If the company doctor says you need a particular test or treatment, you are almost certainly entitled to it.  Employers are obligated to pay all reasonable medical care for employees who are hurt on the job. It will be very hard to argue that he doctor selected by your employer to care for you has unreasonably suggested that you need a MRI.

An experienced worker’s compensation attorney can help you get the medical care you deserve and, if you have a long-term problem as a result of your injury, help you receive benefits for permanent partial disability. 

I just settled my personal injury case and my lawyer told me that I have to re-pay my medical insurance company the amount they paid for my medical bills from the accident.  That doesn’t seem fair.  Is my lawyer right?

Your lawyer is probably right.  Most medical insurance policies have what are known as subrogation  or reimbursement clauses.  These insurance policy provisions  mean that if you get hurt and collect medical bills paid by your insurance company from the person who hurt you your insurance company gets paid back. 

If your insurance through a government-sponsored program like Tenncare or Medicare you also have a responsibility to re-pay the government out of any settlement you receive as a result of a car accident.

I have read this stuff about Herman Cain and the claims of sexual harassment against him.  I also heard that there was a confidentiality agreement as part of the settlement with the woman or women.  What is a confidentiality agreement?

A confidentiality agreement is a part of some settlement agreements in some types of civil litigation.  Typically, confidentiality agreements prohibit the parties from discussing the terms of the settlement with any one other than attorneys and financial advisors.  Confidentiality agreements may also include anti-disparagement provisions, which means that each of the parties to the agreement are prohibited from saying disparaging things about the other parties.  It is not uncommon for these agreements to provide that the parties are cannot talk about the facts giving rise to suit, the lawsuit itself, or the terms of the settlement, but can say that "the case was settled on terms mutually acceptable to all concerned" or words to that effect.

Confidentiality agreements are common in settlements of medical malpractice cases, products liability cases, employment cases, and very large personal injury and wrongful death cases.  They are used in other types of cases as well. 

Contact Information